Skip to content
Clear the driveway before the family arrives. Free towing.
(Thanksgiving edition)Cash For Junk Cars500Free offers nationwide

Selling tips

Does Carvana or CarMax Buy Old or Junk Cars?

Does Carvana or CarMax buy old or junk cars? What each company's pages say about cars that don't run, damage, mileage and titles, plus dealer trade-ins.

By the Cash For Junk Cars 500 team · Reviewed by Paola Reniery, Operations Manager · Published · Updated

The short answer

Carvana and CarMax both buy old cars, but junk cars are a harder sell. Carvana buys only cars newer than 1992 with a working odometer that it can safely drive. CarMax says it wants to buy almost any car and sends ones that miss its standards to wholesale auction. Dealers take junk trade-ins for little credit.

Do Carvana and CarMax buy old or junk cars? Both buy old cars, with limits, and a junk car is a harder sell at either one. Carvana only takes a car it can safely drive. CarMax says it wants to make an offer on almost any car, though cars that don't meet its standards go to its wholesale auction. A dealer will usually take a junk car as a trade-in, for a small credit.

If your car still runs, an instant offer from either company is worth getting. If it doesn't, Carvana's stated requirements exclude it, CarMax's selling pages don't say how it handles non-runners, and a junk car buyer that tows for free is usually the better fit.

Does Carvana buy old cars?

Carvana buys older cars if they meet three conditions. Its trade-in requirements page says the vehicle must be "newer than 1992," the odometer must work, and Carvana must be able to drive it safely. The same page says it accepts cars with expired registration, except in California, and that all owners on the title must be at the appointment.

There's no mileage cap on that page, so a high-mileage car that runs can still get an offer. A car that won't start, or isn't safe to drive, fails the last condition.

To sell, Carvana's sell my car page says it usually asks for photos of your ID, the title and the odometer. Its offers are good for 7 days, and the help center says an offer won't change at the appointment if what you told Carvana matches the car. If the details don't match, it generates an updated offer.

Does CarMax buy old cars that don't run?

CarMax says it's interested in buying "pretty much any car," but its selling pages don't say whether that includes a car that doesn't run. The same CarMax help page explains that a car that doesn't make the cut for its lot goes to its wholesale auction.

CarMax also explains what keeps a car off its retail lots. For the cars it resells, it checks each car's history to rule out flood damage, frame damage, outstanding liens and salvage history, and a car that can't meet those standards "gets sold at auction" (CarMax). Those rules describe the cars CarMax sells. Its pages don't turn them into a list of cars it refuses to buy.

To complete a sale, CarMax lists the title or payoff information, a valid and current registration, a state-issued photo ID for every titleholder and all the keys. The sell my car page says offers are firm and valid for 7 days, and that CarMax verifies the car before finalizing, so differences between your description and the car's actual condition, use or history can change the offer. The same page says at-home pickup isn't available everywhere and that distance restrictions and a fee may apply. If your car doesn't run, call the store before you do anything else. Ask whether it will appraise a car that doesn't run and how it wants the car brought in, since a tow you pay for comes out of what you keep.

What do Carvana and CarMax say about damage, mileage and titles?

Neither company's selling pages cover every junk car situation. Here's what they say, and where they're silent. Checked against Carvana's and CarMax's help and sell-my-car pages in November 2026.

Your car Carvana's pages CarMax's pages
Doesn't run Must be safe for Carvana to drive Not addressed directly; wants to buy "pretty much any car"
Major damage Not addressed beyond the safe-to-drive rule Frame or flood damage keeps a car off its lots; those cars are sold at auction
Very high mileage No cap stated; odometer must work No cap stated
Salvage or rebuilt title Not addressed Salvage history keeps a car off its lots; its selling pages don't say whether it buys one
Missing title Asks for a photo of the title in most cases Asks for the title or payoff information
Expired registration Accepted, except in California Asks for a valid and current registration

Where a page is silent, check their site or ask before you rely on an offer. A branded title can change what a car is worth to any buyer, and our guide to salvage and rebuilt titles explains why. If the title is missing, read how to sell a junk car without a title.

Will a dealership take a junk car as a trade-in?

Dealers will usually take a junk car in trade when you're buying from them, but the credit is usually close to what they can get for it wholesale or as scrap. A dealer can put a trade-in on its own lot, send it to a dealer auction or sell it to a scrap or salvage buyer. A car that needs an engine, or has rust through the floor, is more likely headed for one of the last two.

The trade-in can also blur the numbers. The Federal Trade Commission advises buyers to "wait to discuss the possibility of a trade-in until after you've negotiated the best possible price for your new car," so the seller doesn't raise the sales price to make up for a generous trade-in offer (FTC). The FTC also warns that if you owe more on the car than it's worth, rolling that balance into the new deal can increase what you borrow, how long you pay or your monthly payment. A separate cash offer for the junk car gives you a number to hold the dealer's credit against.

When will an instant-offer site turn you down or offer less?

Instant offers depend on the car matching a short online description, so anything outside the usual case tends to lower the offer or end it. These are the limits the companies' own pages point to:

  1. The car doesn't run or isn't safe to drive (Carvana's stated rule).
  2. The odometer doesn't work (also Carvana's rule).
  3. The car is a 1992 model or older (Carvana).
  4. Not every owner on the title can be at the appointment (both companies).
  5. Frame damage, flood damage or salvage history, which CarMax says send a car to auction instead of its lots.
  6. The car turns out different from your description at pickup or at the store, which leads to a revised offer at both companies.
  7. You wait more than 7 days, after which the offer expires.

Should you try Carvana or CarMax before a junk car buyer?

Try an instant offer first if the car starts, drives safely, has a working odometer and has a clean title in your name. It only takes a few minutes, and a car that runs can be worth more to a used car retailer than to a junk buyer.

Go straight to a junk car buyer if any of these apply:

  • The car doesn't start or isn't safe to drive.
  • It has flood or frame damage.
  • The title is missing, branded or not in your name.
  • A pickup fee or a tow to the store would eat most of the offer.

Whichever route you take, compare what you'd keep after any pickup fee or towing cost.

What are the alternatives for a junk car?

For a car that doesn't run or has major damage, a buyer that prices it on weight and parts and tows it for free is usually the better fit. Junk car buyers start from metal value, roughly $310 for a complete midsize sedan at November 2026 prices, and pay more for parts they can resell. Our guide to who gives the most cash for junk cars explains how to compare them on what you're paid after towing.

If you haven't settled on selling yet, how to get rid of an old car compares seven options, from a private sale to donating.

How do you get a junk car offer to compare?

Have the year, make, model and an honest description of the car's condition ready, then request a free offer. Cash For Junk Cars 500 passes it to our buyer partner, which makes the offer and includes free towing. Set that number next to any instant offer or trade-in credit you have, and keep whichever leaves you with more.

Frequently asked questions

How old of a car will Carvana buy?

Carvana's trade-in requirements say it accepts vehicles newer than 1992. The odometer must work and Carvana has to be able to drive the car safely, so a car that won't start or isn't safe to drive doesn't qualify.

Is it better to sell a car to Carvana or CarMax?

It depends on the car. Both companies' offers last 7 days. Carvana needs a car it can drive safely, while CarMax says it wants to buy almost any car, though its at-home pickup isn't available everywhere and may carry a fee. Get both and keep whichever leaves you more after fees.

Does CarMax buy cars with salvage titles?

CarMax's selling pages don't say. It says it wants to buy almost any car and sends cars that don't make its lot to its wholesale auction. Check their site or ask a store before you count on an offer.

What cars will CarMax not take?

CarMax's selling pages don't list cars it refuses. It says it's interested in buying pretty much any car. Its standards apply to the cars it resells: it rules out flood damage, frame damage, outstanding liens and salvage history for those, and cars that can't meet the standards go to auction instead of its lots.

Will a dealer give me trade-in credit for a junk car?

Usually, but not much. The credit tends to reflect what the dealer can get at auction or for scrap. The FTC suggests settling the price of the car you're buying before you discuss the trade-in.

How long is a Carvana or CarMax offer good for?

Both companies say their offers are valid for 7 days. Each can revise the offer if the car's condition or history doesn't match what you reported.

Ready to sell your junk car?

Request a free offer in about two minutes, or call with questions. Towing is free and you're paid at pickup.

Call nowGet my offer